Redrock Outdoors Home Page Redrock Outdoors Home Page Redrock Outdoors Home Page Redrock Outdoors Home Page
Home > Land Use Issues > Specific Issues

Land Use Issues
 Specific Land Closure

 Dam Decommissions

 

 

 

 
 
 

 - The various issues we're following -

We're proud to be a member of the Friends of Lake Powell Organization
   Here's where we're covering the specific issues that are most important to us.  Some of these are specific land closure movements, others are movements that are trying to drain reservoirs and as we find other things we want to take a stand on, you'll find them here.  Be warned, we are taking a stand here.  We're going to try to present objective information from both sides of these debates, but we're not afraid to say what we're opposed to.

- Specific Land Closure Issues -

    Southern Utah is an area that is currently embroiled in a bitter, very vocal and public land battle.  It didn't start with President Clintons' creation of the Grand Staircase - Escalante National Monument, but that action brought much of the battle into the news lately.  But prior to that, the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance had been working dilligently to close millions of acres of Southern Utah to all forms of mechanized travel.  This fight started in the mid-80's when a Bureau of Land Management inventory of public lands in Utah came up with a total of about 2.7 million acres of land in Utah that they felt should be classified as Wilderness.  Many felt that his inventory was done poorly, that the results were wrong and that the BLM was basically totally clueless.  An organization was formed, the Utah Wilderness Coalition, and their contention was that 5.1 million acres of Utah should be classified as wilderness.  Not much later, they revised their number to 5.7 million acres.  5.7 million acres is said to be the absolute correct number, non-negotiable by the Wilderness advocates.  

   In 1989, Utah congressman Wayne Owens presented America's Redrock Wilderness Bill, formalizing the fight to make 5.7 million acres the final number for this wilderness classification.  

   In 1993, New York Congressman Maurice Hinchey assumed sponsorship of this this resolution, known officially as H.R. 1500.

   In 1995, Governor Leavitt announced plans to work with Utah congressional representatives to present H.R. 1745 which called for 1.8 millions acres to recieve wilderness classification.

   In 1996, Clinton's creation of the Grand Staircase - Escalante National Monument included 1.3 million acres of the land that SUWA wants protected but the battle continued.

   In the summer of 1998, SUWA announces that the original "final" number of 5.7 million acres has now grown to 9.1 million acres, based on their own inventory.  They take their case on the road, presenting public meetings in Utah as well as Boston, San Francisco, Seattle, Denver and Atlanta.  Their claim is that public support for wilderness designation of their new 9.1 million acre number is overwhelming.  We wonder if any of the folks from Boston or Atlanta have ever visited Utah.  Probably not.  

   In 1999 the BLM released their revised inventory, and restated their wilderness designation number at 5.8 million acres.  Hmm, pretty close the original "final" SUWA number of 5.7 million acres, don't you think?  Interesting how SUWA raised their "final" number to 9.1 when it began to look as if the BLM was going to meet their initial request.

- Dam Decommissions -

 Lake Powell - Glen Canyon Dam

   Initially brought forward by the Sierra Club, the movement to Drain Lake Powell and decommission the Glen Canyon Dam is still promoted by the Glen Canyon Action Network.

Flaming Gorge - Flaming Gorge Dam
   The movement to restore the entire Colorado River drainage that is promoted by the Glen Canyon Action Network and others would also include decommissioning the Flaming Gorge dam.  These groups maintain that the flood control, irrigation and power generation benefits of these man made dams are no longer issues, and that we should simply breach these dams and return the Colorado and Green Rivers to their natural wild state.  Given the state of the current power generation facilities of the Western United States (in this summer or routine rolling blackouts across California) we wonder how anyone can say we don't need clean, efficient Hydro-Electric power generation.